I think It would be nice if more well written characters (EX: Dr. Sterk or Ulthrik Dreemurr) to be separated from characters who are "Cringe Inducing" (EX: Gill (Female sans who's also a potential sans ship child... and a potential Mary sue), Justice! sans (Frans character who's also semi-OP), and Infinitey code (Do I have to explain?)). It could really Inspire people to make more Interesting and unique OCs, and while it would seem rather rude to call someone's OC "dainted, dire, bad.", I find it rather necessary. How I see It would be for there to be two additional categories:
Dire - any Mediocre OCs who are
A mary sue
A frans character (or based on a similar ship)
Has little to no writing other than "They are ______" (must at least have some background, unless they're an NPC character or of similar grounds)
Is just a sans/Frisk/Undertale character Recolor with overpowered abilities
Everyone likes them "just because"
Is overpowered, Broken, and without flaws (especially the latter, and the former cannot be justified with "Just because".) (Ulthrik and Sterk can easily be excluded from this category since they both have flaws and have reasoning behind their abilities. Ulthrik is a boss monster, and Sterk Is a lich.)
Lucid - any well written OCs who
Have their own place in their own story, or just plain cool.
Can be an NPC, minor role, or even a major role (think of Itsy & bitsy, or red.)
Must not Harbor what makes a character "Dire".
Overall, I just wanna hear everyone's thoughts on this. I think It could really distinguish a Good character with one who's just "Outcode! Infinity! 404! Bill! Swap! female! sans".